Madam Deputy Speaker Nusrat Ghani condemned the government following the unprecedented accidental publishing of the Budget by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR).
Addressing the Chamber, she criticised the disappointing level of media engagement before the official announcement, stating that these actions fell short of the standards expected by the House of Commons. She reminded the Government that announcements should be made in the Chamber before being released to the media.
Madam Deputy Speaker Ghani said: "For a number of weeks, and yet again yesterday, there have been extensive briefings to the media on the Government’s fiscal policy and public finances. This disappointing trend in relation to Budget briefings has been growing for a number of years under successive Governments, but it appears to have reached an unprecedented high. Weeks ago, we saw the Chancellor delivering a speech in Downing Street setting the scene for the Budget, and specific policy announcements have been briefed out to the media in advance of today’s financial statement. I do not need any help from Members. It seems that just a moment ago, the Office for Budget Responsibility’s analysis appeared online. This all falls short of the standards that the House expects. The premature disclosure of the contents of the Budget has always been regarded as a supreme discourtesy to this House and to all the democratically elected Members, not to mention to Mr Speaker, and to me, the Chairman of Ways and Means.
The Government’s own “Ministerial Code” cannot be clearer. Paragraph 9.1 states:
“When Parliament is in session, the most important announcements of Government policy should be made in the first instance in Parliament.”
I have always upheld the right of this House and its Members to be treated with respect, and to be the first to hear major Government policy announcements on behalf of their constituents. As Chairman of Ways and Means, I have responsibility for overseeing the House’s consideration of the Budget statement and the ensuing resolutions; that is described in paragraph 36.33 of “Erskine May” as “the most important business of Ways and Means.” I want hon. Members on both sides of the House to have adequate opportunity to hold the Chancellor to account, rather than their hearing and reading about new policies daily in the media. Like many, I expected better."
